This American Life - white families and black dolls

Would your child "adopt" a doll of a different race?

Posted by: Marcialou
by: Marcialou 01/16/2009 12:56:05 AM
Re: This American Life - white families and black dolls
I just listened to "This American Life" from 1/9/09 on the subject of matchmakers. In Act 3, Elna Baker tells the story of her job in the doll "adoption" center at FAO Schwartz, where a craze for the Lee Middleton baby dolls led to a shortage of white babies. White mothers and their daughters coped by "making do" with Asian and Latino adoptees but they left the black dolls to languish in their little toy incubators.

This discomforting story reminded me of a similarly discomforting time in my own family's life. About 20 years ago when some other baby doll was all the rage, my daughter, age 5 or so, wanted one *really* badly. When I got to the store, only the black ones were left. I hesitated for a moment, pulled one from the shelf, and added it to my cart. I was saddened but not completely surprised when upon receiving the gift, my daughter rejected it.

"If you really don't want it, I can bring it back to the store," I said. "Someone will buy it for another little girl who will love it and take good care of it." I gave it to Goodwill and hoped it would find a good home.

I hope 2009 will be different from 2008 in many ways but one thing comes especially to mind as I write this. I hope that when the Malia and Sasha dolls come out they will be the rage among little girls of all colors. I suspect my daughter, more open minded as an adult than she was as a child, will be first in line to buy one for her little niece.

Marcia
Updated: 01/16/2009 09:48:28 AM
Flag comment as inappropriate
by: Anonymous 01/26/2010 5:26:59 PM
Re: This American Life - white families and black dolls
I'm a member of a doll club. It's amazing to me the number of our members who don't own a single african american doll. They will happily include asian dolls and even hispanic dolls in their collection but reject black dolls out of hand.
It's really sad!!
by: Natty CitizenHuman 02/02/2010 10:35:49 AM
Re: This American Life - white families and black dolls
When a white household doesn't positively highlights blackness, then white kids pick on that and as well as what media and neighbours say. In a white neighbourhood, the media and the society often is engaged in stereotypes. Lord forbid if a white kid from this environment gets in a fight with a black kid at school... while such would be because of 'kids being kids', somehow racially charged emotion is instigated (even by parental talk) and rest of upbringing becomes defensive to blacks, dislike to blacks... this is the sad part. What parents and society do or doesn't do in raising their kids with positive and fair outlook towards blacks. I believe kids are born not judging people on race but merits, but are taught to start judging along racial lines and stereotypes. The irony is how parents themselves are consciously or subconsciously perpetuating same stereotypical bs their parents had fed them without even recognising that era has changed. Parents, especially American parents, have a duty to teach their children how to live positively in a melting pot society. Foundation of racism or righteousness starts at home, not at school and not at church or else.

RSS

Powered by Public Interactive